From: | Aimee Houghton <aimeeh@igc.org> |
Date: | Mon, 16 Jun 1997 11:43:19 -0700 (PDT) |
Reply: | cpeo-military |
Subject: | EPA CEASE FIRE ORDER - Part 1 |
As many of you know we have been following and posting information regarding issues surrounding the Massachusetts Military Range (MMR). Below is the first of three parts of the Cease Fire Order issued by U.S. EPA Region 1. I will post all thre parts seperately as they are long files. Aimee Houghton ________________________________________ UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY REGION I ________________________________________ ) In the Matter of: ) U.S. EPA Region I ) Training Range and Impact Area, ) EPA Docket No.: Massachusetts Military Reservation ) ) SDWA I-97-1019 ) ) National Guard Bureau, ) ) ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER Respondent ) FOR RESPONSE ACTION ) Proceeding Under Section 1431(a) of the ) Safe Drinking Water Act, 42 U.S.C. ) § 300i(a) ) ________________________________________) ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER FOR: MASSACHUSETTS MILITARY RESERVATION TRAINING RANGE AND IMPACT AREA RESPONSE ACTIONS TABLE OF CONTENTS I. JURISDICTION.................................4 II. STATE COORDINATION...........................4 III. PARTIES BOUND................................4 IV. PURPOSE......................................4 V. DEFINITIONS..................................4 VI. FINDINGS OF FACT.............................5 VII. ENDANGERMENT AND RESPONSE....................8 VIII. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW...........................10 IX. DETERMINATIONS...............................10 X. ORDER........................................11 XI. DESIGNATION OF SUPERVISING CONTRACTOR AND PROJECT COORDINATOR......................11 XII. NOTICE OF INTENT TO COMPLY...................12 XIII. EPA TECHNICAL PROJECT COORDINATOR ...........13 XIV. WORK TO BE PERFORMED; COMPLETION OF WORK...........................13 XV. SUBMISSIONS REQUIRING AGENCY APPROVAL AND RESPONDENT'S OBLIGATION TO PROCEED.......14 XVI. INCORPORATION AND ENFORCEABILITY OF DOCUMENTS....................................15 XVII. ACCESS.......................................15 XVIII. QUALITY ASSURANCE/SAMPLING ..................16 XIX. ACCESS TO INFORMATION; RECORD PRESERVATION; CONFIDENTIALITY CLAIMS.......................16 XX. CREATION OF DANGER; EMERGENCY RESPONSE.......17 XXI. AMENDMENTS ..................................18 XXII. OTHER APPLICABLE LAWS........................19 XXIII. ENFORCEMENT; PENALTIES FOR NONCOMPLIANCE.....19 XXIV. DISCLAIMER OF LIABILITY BY EPA...............19 XXV. NO RELEASE FROM LIABILITY....................19 XXVI. RESERVATION OF RIGHTS BY EPA.................19 XXVII. OPPORTUNITY TO CONFER........................20 XXVIII. EXCUSED DELAY-FORCE MAJEURE..................21 XXIX. EFFECTIVE DATE; COMPUTATION OF TIME..........22 XXX. ANTI-DEFICIENCY ACT..........................22 XXXI. SEVERABILITY.................................22 XXXII. TERMINATION..................................22 I. JURISDICTION 1. This Administrative Order (Order) is issued to Respondent National Guard Bureau pursuant to the authority vested in the Administrator of EPA by Section 1431(a) of the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), 42 U.S.C. § 300i(a). The Administrator of EPA has delegated the authority to take these actions to the Regional Administrator of EPA Region I by EPA Delegation 9-17 (1200-TN-350) dated May 11, 1994. II. STATE COORDINATION 2. Pursuant to Section 1431 of the SDWA, 42 U.S.C. § 300i, EPA consulted with the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and local authorities on this matter. III. PARTIES BOUND 3. This Order shall apply to and be binding upon the Respondent, and upon its affiliated organizations, agents, contractors, and consultants. IV. PURPOSE 4. This Order compels the Respondent to conduct measures to abate the threat to public health presented by the past and present contamination from the Massachusetts Military Reservation (MMR) Training Range and Impact Area by performing the work described more fully in the attached Scope of Work (SOW) appended to this Order as Appendix A, and enforceable hereunder. V. DEFINITIONS 5. All other terms, not otherwise defined herein, shall have their ordinary meanings unless defined in SDWA, in which case the SDWA definition shall control. "Contractor" shall mean any person, including the contractors, subcontractors, or agents, retained or hired by Respondent to undertake any Work under this Order "Day" shall mean a calendar day, unless otherwise specified. "Order" shall mean this SDWA § 1431 Administrative Order, any attachments or appendices to this Order, and all documents that are to be produced or submitted pursuant to this Order. All attachments or appendices to this Order, and all documents that are to be produced or submitted pursuant to this Order are incorporated into this Order, and shall be enforceable hereunder. "Work" shall mean all tasks and activities required by this Order or related to the performance of tasks and activities required by this Order. VI. FINDINGS OF FACT 6. Respondent National Guard Bureau is an agency of the United States Government. 7. The Massachusetts Military Reservation (MMR) is an approximately 22,000 acre facility located on Cape Cod, in the townships of Bourne, Falmouth, Mashpee and Sandwich in Barnstable County, Massachusetts. Respondent's affiliated organization, the Massachusetts Army National Guard, conducts operations at MMR. 8. Approximately 14,000 acres of MMR constitutes the Training Range and Impact Area. For over forty years, military and law enforcement training has been conducted in the Training Range, including the Impact Area. This training has included the following: a. Small arms firing at several ranges in the Training Range and Impact Area involving the use of small caliber munitions; b. Artillery firing from gun and mortar locations in the Training Range into the Impact Area; and c. Detonation practice for explosives at two demolition ranges in or near the Training Range and Impact Area. 9. Up to 1,770,000 small arms rounds are fired annually at the Training Range and Impact Area. 10. The primary chemical constituent of the small arms used by Respondent at MMR is a lead core in a metal alloy jacket, usually composed of lead, copper, iron, antimony, and nickel. 11. In its artillery firing at MMR, munitions are used similar to those used in small arms training as well as explosive compounds. Up to 3,181 rounds of artillery and mortar are fired annually at the Training Range and Impact Area. 12. High explosives used at MMR include trinitrotoluene (TNT) and Royal Demolition Explosive, hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5-triazine (RDX). According to Respondent, TNT has been the most widely used military explosive since World War I. RDX has been used since World War II, and is used in combination with TNT. 13. One location for periodic detonation of explosives, including detonation of RDX and TNT, is known as "Demo 1." Demo 1 is a natural depression directly south of the Impact Area. This natural depression is approximately 30 feet above the ground water table. 14. On July 13, 1982, EPA formally determined that the Cape Cod aquifer is the sole or principal source of drinking water for Cape Cod, Massachusetts, and that the Cape Cod aquifer, if contaminated, would create a significant hazard to public health. 47 Fed. Reg. 30282. Among the findings on which EPA based this determination are the following: a. The Cape Cod aquifer is a single continuous aquifer which then served as the "sole source" of drinking water for the approximately 147,725 permanent residents and 424,445 peak seasonal residents of Cape Cod; b. There is no existing alternative drinking water source, or combination of sources, which provides fifty percent or more of the drinking water to the designated areas, nor is there any reasonably available alternative future source capable of supplying Cape Cod's drinking water demands; and c. As a result of its highly permeable soil characteristics, the Cape Cod aquifer is susceptible to contamination through its recharge zone from a number of sources. Since groundwater contamination can be difficult or impossible to reverse, and since this aquifer is relied on for drinking water purposes by the general population, contamination of the aquifer would pose a significant hazard to public health. 15. Currently the Cape Cod Aquifer serves as the sole drinking water source for approximately 200,000 permanent and 520,000 seasonal residents of Cape Cod. 16. The Training Range and Impact Area lie directly over the Cape Cod Aquifer. The Training Range and Impact Area represent a major groundwater recharge area, located above what may be the apex of the aquifer. Groundwater flows radially in all directions from the Training Range and Impact Area. 17. The part of an aquifer that directly supplies a public water supply well is known as a "wellhead protection area." The Training Range and Impact Area lie directly above segments of several wellhead protection areas on Cape Cod. 18. Groundwater flow under the MMR has been calculated at an average of one to three feet per day; an estimated 6 million gallons of water per day are contaminated by plumes already known to be emanating from MMR. 19. To date, much of the Training Range and Impact Area have not been investigated for groundwater contamination. The only groundwater investigations performed to date in the Training Range and Impact Area are as follows: investigation of a chemical spill (CS-19) undertaken by the National Guard Bureau, and now the Air Force, as part of the overall MMR Installation Restoration Program (IRP); and sampling of wells near the perimeter of the Training Range and Impact Area as part of efforts to identify a long range water supply for Cape Cod. 20. In groundwater sampling undertaken as part of the IRP within the Impact Area in 1994, RDX was detected in two wells at concentrations of 6 and 22 parts per billion (ppb). 21. In groundwater sampling undertaken as part of the IRP within the Impact Area in 1995, RDX was detected in two wells at concentrations of 5.4 ppb and 19 ppb. 22. In soil sampling performed as part of the IRP in 1992, lead was detected in soils in the Impact Area at concentrations up to 1,830 parts per million (ppm). Other contaminants found in soils within the Impact Area include inorganic chemicals other than lead; volatile organic compounds; herbicides, dioxins, and furans; and explosive compounds. 23. Groundwater sampling was performed downgradient and outside of the Training Range and Impact Area as part of the long range water supply investigation for Cape Cod. During such sampling, lead was detected in one well near the Impact Area at 17 ppb. 24. In groundwater sampling undertaken downgradient and outside of the Training Range and Impact Area in July 1996 by a consultant for the Air Force Center for Environmental Excellence (AFCEE) as part of a study of options for a long-range water supply for the area, trinitrotoluene (TNT) was reported to be detected in a well at a concentration of .27 ppb. VII. ENDANGERMENT AND RESPONSE 25. The detection of RDX, lead, and TNT in groundwater samples from the sole source aquifer underlying Cape Cod demonstrates the release or threat of release of contaminants from the Training Range and Impact Area. 26. EPA's Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response (OSWER) Directive 9850.3, Chemical, Physical & Biological Properties of Compounds Present at Hazardous Waste Sites, identifies the hazard criteria for chemical compounds typically found at hazardous waste sites. The hazard criteria identify the specific categories for which chemical compounds have demonstrated a toxic effect. The hazard criteria listed for lead in this Directive are: reproductive toxicity, teratogenicity, chronic toxicity, domestic animal toxicity, and environmental toxicity. 27. Teratogens and reproductive toxins are compounds that have suggestive evidence of an effect in humans or a clearly "positive" result in at least one study in whole animals. Unsupported in vitro evidence is considered sufficient to classify a chemical as a reproductive or teratogenic hazard. 28. Chronic toxins are compounds that produce serious irreversible effects, other than cancer or reproductive effects, after extended oral, dermal or inhalation exposures. 29. Domestic animal toxins are compounds that cause a demonstrated serious toxic effect that has been seen in the field. Oral doses of chemicals that cause reproductive toxicity, teratogenicity, or subchronic toxicity may also be included as domestic animal toxins. 30. Environmental toxins are chemicals that are hazardous to either aquatic organisms or terrestrial wildlife. 31. EPA has established lifetime health advisories for contaminants, which provide the concentration of a chemical in drinking water that is not expected to cause any adverse non-carcinogenic effect over a lifetime of exposure with a margin of safety. The lifetime health advisory for RDX is 2 ppb. 32. Consumption of large amounts of RDX by humans has caused seizures, indicating that the nervous system is a primary target organ. 33. A 1984 Department of Defense study of female mice showed an increased incidence of liver tumors following chronic oral exposure to RDX. 34. In its cancer classification system, EPA has classified RDX as a possible human carcinogen (Group C carcinogen). 35. The lifetime health advisory for TNT is 2 ppb. 36. Chronic exposure to TNT by humans has been associated with skin irritation and cataracts. Exposure to very high levels of TNT in the workplace have been associated with disorders of the blood and abnormal liver functions. 37. Oral and inhalation exposures to TNT in animals have resulted in adverse effects on the blood and liver as well as the spleen and immune system. TNT has been found to cause serious effects on the male reproductive system in rats following high exposures to TNT. In a 1984 U.S. Army study, TNT was found to cause urinary bladder tumors in female Fisher rats. 38. In its cancer classification system, EPA has classified TNT as a possible human carcinogen (Group C carcinogen). 39. Pursuant to Section 1412 of SDWA, EPA has established a Maximum Contaminant Level Goal (MCLG) of zero for lead in drinking water. MCLGs are set at levels at which no known or anticipated adverse health effects will occur. Further, for certain public drinking water supply systems, EPA has established 15 ppb as the level at which corrosion control systems must be established in order to reduce lead levels in drinking water. 40. Lead is a reproductive hazard that can adversely affect the brain and central nervous system by causing encephalopathy and peripheral neuropathy. Lead exposure across a broad range of blood lead levels has been associated with a spectrum of pathophysiological effects, including interference with heme synthesis necessary for formation of red blood cells, anemia, kidney damage, impaired reproductive function, interference with vitamin D metabolism, impaired cognitive performance (as measured by IQ tests, performance in school and other means), delayed physical development, and elevations in blood pressure. 41. The continued release of RDX, lead and TNT, and any release of other contaminants from the Training Range and Impact Area, may present an imminent and substantial endangerment to the health of persons. 42. The Work specified in the SOW appended to this Order will include, but not be limited to, the following: providing EPA and the public with any and all information in Respondent's possession or control on known or potential contaminants in soil and groundwater on, near and emanating from the Training Range and Impact Area; providing to EPA and the public an accelerated schedule and work plan for completing an independent, comprehensive study of the effects on public health from past, present, and future activities on and near the Training Range and Impact Area; and ensuring adequate public involvement in all the Work undertaken pursuant to this Order. This Work is necessary to prevent, minimize, and/or mitigate the threat of an imminent and substantial endangerment to the health of persons posed by the actual or potential releases of RDX, lead, TNT and other contaminants into the surface soils and groundwater at and emanating from the Training Range and Impact Area. VIII. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based on the foregoing, EPA makes the following Conclusions of Law: 43. Respondent is a "person" as that term is defined in Section 1401(12) of the SDWA, 42 U.S.C. § 300f(12). 44. The RDX, lead and TNT found in the groundwater beneath or near the Training Range and Impact Area are "contaminants", as that term is defined in Section 1401(6) of SDWA, 42 U.S.C. § 300f(6). 45. The RDX, lead and TNT found in the groundwater beneath or near the Training Range and Impact Area are present in or likely to enter the Cape Cod Aquifer. 46. The Cape Cod Aquifer is an "underground source of drinking water", as that term is defined in 40 C.F.R. Section 144.3. IX. DETERMINATIONS Based on the foregoing and the EPA Administrative Record for this Order, EPA has determined that: 47. The contaminants present in or likely to enter the underground source of drinking water may present an imminent and substantial endangerment to the health of persons, within the meaning of Section 1431(a) of SDWA, 42 U.S.C. § 300i(a). 48. Respondent has caused or contributed to the endangerment described immediately above. 49. In accordance with the requirements of Section 1431 of the SDWA, EPA determines that the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and local authorities have not taken the actions necessary to protect the health of persons whose sole source of drinking water is the Cape Cod Aquifer (i.e. they have not ordered the steps required by this order). 50. The actions required by this Order are necessary to protect the health of persons who are or may be users of the Cape Cod Aquifer. Based on the endangerment described above, the response actions in this Order are necessary. The response actions will consist of Respondent's implementation of the Scope of Work appended to this Order. The Scope of Work is designed to prevent, minimize, and/or mitigate damage to the health which may otherwise result from the release or threat of release of contaminants. X. ORDER 51. Based on EPA's jurisdiction, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law set forth above, the Administrative Record supporting issuance of this Order, and in order to abate or prevent any imminent and substantial endangerment to health, the Respondent is ORDERED to perform all Work required under this Order. The Respondent shall comply with the following provisions and perform all actions required by the terms and conditions of this Order. XI. DESIGNATION OF SUPERVISING CONTRACTOR AND PROJECT COORDINATOR 52. Within seven (7) days after the effective date of this Order, the Respondent shall retain the services of a qualified and experienced Supervising Contractor for the purpose of performing the work required by this Order in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Scope of Work. Within the same seven (7) day period, the Respondent shall notify EPA in writing of the name, address, and qualifications of the proposed supervising contractor and the name and telephone number of the supervising contractor's primary contact person. The Respondent shall also notify EPA of the identity and qualifications of any other contractor(s) or subcontractor(s) to be used at least seven (7) days in advance of their performing any work under this Order. 53. The supervising contractor shall be a qualified professional with substantial expertise and experience in the investigation and cleanup of hazardous waste sites and contaminated groundwater. EPA reserves the right to disapprove, based on professional qualifications, conflicts of interest, and/or deficiencies in previous similar work, any contractor or subcontractor or other person engaged directly or indirectly by the Respondent to conduct work activities under this Order. If EPA disapproves the selection of any proposed contractor, the Respondent shall notify EPA in writing of the name, address, and qualifications of another contractor within seven (7) days after receipt of the notice of disapproval. 54. The Respondent shall provide a copy of this Order to all contractors, subcontractors, laboratories, and consultants retained in connection with this Order within seven (7) days after the Order's effective date or of such retention, whichever is later. The Respondent shall ensure that all such contractors, subcontractors, laboratories and consultants will perform all work in conformity with SDWA, and the terms and conditions of this Order and Scope of Work. Respondent shall nonetheless be responsible for ensuring that its contractors and subcontractors perform the Work in accordance with this Order. 55. Within seven (7) days after the effective date of this Order, the Respondent shall designate a Project Coordinator who shall be responsible for administration of all of the Respondent's actions called for by this Order, and shall submit the designated coordinator's name, address, and telephone number to EPA. EPA will deem the project coordinator's receipt of any notice or communication from EPA relating to this Order as receipt by the Respondent. XII. NOTICE OF INTENT TO COMPLY 56. Respondent shall provide, within five (5) days after the effective date of this Order, written notice to EPA stating whether Respondent will comply with the terms of this Order. If Respondent does not unequivocally commit to perform the work required by this Order, Respondent shall be deemed to have violated this Order and to have failed or refused to comply with this Order. The absence of a response by EPA to the notice required by this paragraph shall not be deemed to be acceptance of Respondent's assertions. XIII. EPA TECHNICAL PROJECT COORDINATOR 57. The EPA Technical Project Coordinator (TPC) will administer EPA's responsibilities and receive all written notices, reports, plans and other documents required by this Order. Within five days after the effective date of this Order, EPA will notify Respondent of the identity of EPA's Project Coordinator. All submissions required by this Order shall be sent to EPA's TPC at the following address: Attention: MMR Impact Area Technical Project Coordinator U.S. Environmental Protection Agency J.F.K. Federal Building Boston, MA 02203-2211 58. EPA's TPC shall have the authority to modify the Scope of Work in writing. Absence of the TPC from the MMR shall not be cause for stoppage of work by the Respondent unless specifically directed by the TPC. XIV. WORK TO BE PERFORMED; COMPLETION OF WORK 59. Immediately after retention of the supervising contractor, the Respondent shall commence the work detailed in the Scope of Work. All work performed by the Respondent shall be conducted in accordance with SDWA, applicable guidance documents provided by EPA, and the provisions of this Order including any standards, specifications, and time schedules contained in the Scope of Work or specified by the TPC. 60. Within forty-five (45) days after completing all work required under this Order, the Respondent shall submit for EPA approval a Completion of Work Report summarizing the activities conducted pursuant to the Scope of Work. The Completion of Work Report shall include the categories of information and conform to the requirements specified in the Scope of Work. The Completion of Work Report shall be certified by the supervising contractor, to the effect that all response activities have been completed in full satisfaction of the requirements of this Order. 61. When EPA deter-mines that all work has been fully performed in accordance with this Order, and that all goals and objectives of this Order and the Scope of Work have been satisfied, EPA will provide written notice to the Respondent. If EPA determines that all response activities have not been completed in accordance with the provisions of this Order, it will so notify the Respondent and provide a list of the tasks remaining and a schedule for their completion. The Respondent shall perform all remaining tasks and shall submit an amended Completion of Work Report in accordance with the EPA notice. If EPA determines that the remaining tasks have not been completed in accordance with the provisions of the EPA notice and this Order, the Respondent shall be in violation of this Order. 62. EPA's issuance of the notice referred to in the paragraph immediately above shall not preclude it from later determining, based upon new information or otherwise, that the Respondent has not completed all response activities in accordance with the provisions of this Order. XV. SUBMISSIONS REQUIRING AGENCY APPROVAL; RESPONDENT'S OBLIGATION TO PROCEED 63. After review of any deliverable, plan, report or other item (submission) which the Respondent is required to submit for review and approval pursuant to this Order and Scope of Work, EPA may: (i) approve the submission; (ii) conditionally approve the submission with required modifications; (iii) disapprove the submission and notify the Respondent of deficiencies; or (iv) disapprove the submission and modify the deliverable, plan, report, or other item itself to cure any deficiencies. In the event EPA approves or conditionally approves the submission, or disapproves and modifies the submission itself, the Respondent shall perform all actions required by the submission, as approved, conditionally approved, or modified by EPA. 64. Upon receipt of a notice of disapproval with deficiencies ((iii) above), the Respondent shall correct the deficiencies and resubmit the submission within seven (7) days or such other time period specified in the notice of disapproval. Notwithstanding a notice of disapproval, the Respondent shall proceed to take any action required by any non-deficient portion of the submission. If EPA does not approve the submission as resubmitted, Respondent shall be in violation of the Order. 65. For each submission provided to EPA, the Respondent shall submit such copies as specified by the TPC. Any deliverable, plan, or report submitted to EPA pursuant to this Order shall be dated and shall include, in a prominent location in the document, the following disclaimer: "Disclaimer: This document has been prepared pursuant to a government administrative order (U.S. EPA Region I SDWA Docket No. I-97-1019) and is subject to approval by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The opinions, findings, and conclusions expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency." In addition, any such deliverable, plan, or report which has not received final approval from EPA shall be marked "Draft" on each page. XVI. INCORPORATION AND ENFORCEABILITY OF DOCUMENTS 66. The Scope of Work and all other appendices or attachments to this Order shall be deemed incorporated into, and made an enforceable part of, this Order. Upon approval by EPA, all contracts, deliverables, plans, reports, specifications, schedules, or other items required by or developed under this Order shall be deemed incorporated into, and made an enforceable part of, this Order. In the event of conflict between this Order and any document attached to, incorporated into, or enforceable hereunder, the provisions of this Order shall control. XVII. ACCESS 67. To the extent Respondent owns, occupies, leases or controls property at the MMR, or property other than the MMR to which access is required in order to properly carry out the terms of this Order, it shall grant access to EPA, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts (the "State") and their officers, employees, agents, contractors, consultants, and other authorized representatives for purposes of implementing and monitoring work to be performed under this Order. 68. To the extent access to, use or ownership of, or easements over property other than the MMR are required for the proper and complete implementation of this Order, the Respondent shall use its best efforts to obtain access agreements or other interests in the property, in writing, sufficient to allow implementation of this Order within twenty-one (21) days after the Order's effective date. For purposes of this paragraph, "best efforts" include but are not limited to the payment of money, consistent with the Anti-Deficiency Act, in consideration of access to property. 69. Such written access agreements or other interests obtained pursuant to the preceding paragraph shall provide EPA, the State, and their officers, employees, agents, contractors, consultants, and other authorized representatives access to the MMR at all times for purposes of implementing and monitoring work under this Order. Such written access agreements or other interests shall specify that the Respondent is not EPA's representative or agent with respect to liability associated with the MMR. 70. In the event that access agreements or other interests sufficient for implementation and monitoring of work under this Order are not obtained within the time period specified above, the Respondent shall notify EPA in writing within three (3) days thereafter regarding the lack of such agree-ments and the efforts made by the Respondent to obtain them. Lack of access shall not excuse or justify failure to perform any activity or to meet any deadline | |
Prev by Date: Re: BASE CLOSURE SETBACK Next by Date: EPA CEASE FIRE ORDER Part 2 | |
Prev by Thread: NRDC H.R. 1778 Sign-On Letter (URGENT) Next by Thread: EPA CEASE FIRE ORDER Part 2 |